Serving the Evansville area since 2005

Historic Downtown Newburgh
Fresh Coastal Flavors

At The Tin Fish, we bring the coast to your table with fresh seafood delivered up to 6 days a week. Enjoy oysters, seafood platters, cocktails, and more in a casual, welcoming atmosphere—whether dining indoors or outdoors.

Special offer located here • Special offer located here • Special offer located here.

CHANGING THE TIDE IN NEWBURGH'S

SEAFOOD SCENE

Since 2005, The Tin Fish has been a local favorite and premiere seafood destination in the Evansville area. Independently owned and operated in historic downtown Newburgh,
Chef Morgan Close Castillo prides herself in the quality and consistency of her service and coastal seafood menu; with fresh fish delivered daily. The Tin Fish is a friendly, often bustling, always casual, place to enjoy icy cold piles of chubby oysters, delicious seafood platters, wine by the glass, beer, and smart cocktails.

On the menu at the bar

Sip, savor, and unwind with our selection of wines by the glass, craft beers, and signature cocktails—perfectly paired with your favorite seafood.

what our customers are saying

Richard Sambol

13 days ago

Dinner Six blue pount oysters were fresh. Good stuff. Cod fish and chips were hot and crispy. You order first at a counter then they bring your food to you. Staff was very attentive. We'll run operation.

Brittany L.

15 days ago

If I could only pick one place to dine out, it would be Tin Fish, no question! The service is always above and beyond, it has a comfortable but stylish decor and vibe. However, the food is something else... I am convinced the owner/chef and often cook has a bottle of secret fairy magic she sprinkles on everything! Try the specials, and special sides, that is where you get even a little more of the good stuff!

Darrell Damrath

19 days ago

Catfish was really good

Jenn

20 days ago

You order at the counter when you get inside then you seat yourself. We really enjoyed the patio, it was a beautiful day and there was plenty of shaded spots or spots in the sun. We got lobster Mac and cheese bites to start. They were served with ranch and were so yummy and crispy. Then we both got a blackened Mahi Mahi sandwich served on pumpernickel bread with pickle, onion, tomato and tarter. The sandwich was super flavorful and the fish was cooked perfectly! Their homemade hot sauce was a great addition to the food also. Great flavor and not too hot. All around it was a perfect meal and the atmosphere was great. We will be back!!!

Rebecca Heckert

42 days ago

The Tin Fish has lots of great options for everyone. The bacon cheeseburger was fantastic, as well as the blackened chicken sandwich. Fries and onion rings were good also.

Garry Slankard

54 days ago

One of my very top favorites. Food and service is excellent.

Hayhurst F.

57 days ago

Always great we love it here the atmosphere and the food is great I miss their old location, but the new location obviously is very nice.

Whitney Jo

60 days ago

This was my first time there. I enjoyed the food. Recommend their catfish bites. The staff was welcoming and friendly.

Jenna Hancock-Wargel

97 days ago

We love the food here wish we had one on westside just saying:)

Steve D

137 days ago

Helpful staff. Clean restarant. Most important, they know how to perfectly cook seafood. Best oysters I've had outside louisiana. This place is worth going out of your way.

Lora Becker

147 days ago

A relaxing place to catch up with good friends. Order at the register, then sit back and enjoy!

Benton Frisse

149 days ago

Great local dining spot with lots of seafood options. The cole slaw is delicious, along with their famous fish sandwhich. Portion sizes aren't gigantic which I'm not mad about, they're sensible portion sizes. Good beer on tap, too. Fish and chips are also delicious!