About Us
Fresh Seafood, Local Charm
Bringing the Coast to Newburgh
Since 2005, The Tin Fish has been Evansville’s favorite seafood destination, serving coastal flavors in the heart of Indiana.
Independently owned and operated by Chef Morgan Close Castillo, The Tin Fish takes pride in offering seafood delivered fresh up to six days a week. From oysters on ice to signature platters, every dish is crafted with consistency, quality, and a love for great food. Nestled in downtown Newburgh, our restaurant offers both indoor and outdoor seating, welcoming guests to enjoy a casual, friendly atmosphere.
More Than Just Seafood
A Local Favorite Since 2005
From fresh flavors to friendly service, The Tin Fish has become
a beloved spot for locals and visitors alike.
Freshness You Can Taste
Seafood delivered almost daily ensures every dish is packed with flavor.
A Place for Everyone
Whether it’s a quick lunch, lively dinner, or drinks at the bar, our space is warm, casual, and always welcoming.
Community Connection
More than just a restaurant, we’re a gathering spot where friends and families come together.
Seafood, Served Anywhere
Let Tin Fish Cater Your Next Event
Bring the flavors of The Tin Fish to your celebrations with our custom catering services.
Whether you’re planning a family gathering, corporate event, or special celebration, our catering menu brings the same freshness and quality you enjoy at our restaurant straight to your table. From oysters to platters and everything in between, we’ll make your event memorable with food your guests will love.
